The History of Music in the Coptic and Ethiopian Churches

Millions of Christians who live in Egypt and Ethiopia have inherited a rich tradition of worship practices. Each of these churches maintains a variety of ancient worship customs, including the use of music. In Egypt, the congregation participates in the music of worship. The most striking feature of Ethiopian worship is the contribution of the priests, who spend up to several decades mastering the music, poetry, and dance that are used in worship.

The churches of the East can be divided into three groups: first, the Orthodox Churches of the four ancient patriarchs (Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem), together with the now independent churches still in communion with each other: Cyprus, Greece, Russia, Bulgaria, Yugoslavia, and Romania. Second are the Uniate Churches, in union with the church of Rome although following an Eastern rite. These owe their existence to Roman Catholic missionary work in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries and are to be found in small numbers all over Eastern Europe and the Middle East, including the Melkite and Maronite Christians.

The third group of Churches is what the Orthodox church would call heretical. That is, they broke away from the Orthodox, mostly at the time of great doctrinal struggles in about the fifth century. These are the Nestorian church (the Church of East Syria) and the Monophysite Christians consisting of the Jacobite church of Antioch, the Armenian church, the Coptic church, and the Ethiopian church. These last two are particularly good illustrations of the wonderful riches in the Christian music of the area.

The Coptic Church

The words Egypt and Copt have the same basic root and refer to the geographical area around the Nile. The older form, Copt, has become attached to the language spoken in Egypt before Arabic became commonplace about six centuries ago. It is therefore a language that dates back, through the Bohairic dialect, to the ancient Egyptian period.

There may be as many as 7 million Coptic Christians in Egypt today, living in reasonable harmony among at least 40 million Muslims. Some Muslims are becoming more militant and look for an Islamic revolution as a reaction to the increasing poverty and hardship in the country. On the other hand, the Muslim and Christian communities in Egypt have lived in mutual cooperation for centuries and at present that seems set to continue.

Coptic Christians are keenly aware of their ancient ancestry. They revere the apostle Mark as the saint who established the Christian church in Alexandria before his martyrdom there in A.D. 68. They particularly treasure the story of Joseph and Mary’s flight to Egypt with the young Jesus. Many ancient Coptic churches were built to commemorate the various resting places of the Holy Family.

Egypt became one of the great centers of Christian monastic life from the fourth century onwards. Antony (about 251–356) is held to have been the first and finest example of a Christian following a world-renouncing life in the desert.

Many others followed. By the fifteenth century, there may have been as many as 300 monasteries and nunneries in Egypt. At present, there are seven, supporting some 300 monks.

When the Coptic church separated from the Orthodox in the schism of 451, its sense of spiritual and national identity was brought into a sharp focus that has never been lost. As a consequence, the traditions of worship have been less subject to change than in most other Eastern churches.

A visitor to a Coptic church today is immediately aware of being put in touch with very ancient customs which words can only attempt to describe: Perhaps nowhere in the world can you imagine yourself back in so remote an age as when you are in a Coptic church. You go into a strange dark building; at first the European needs an effort to realise that it is a church at all, it looks so different from our usual associations.… In a Coptic church you come into low dark spaces, a labyrinth of irregular openings. There is little light from the narrow windows. Dimly you see strange rich colours and tarnished gold, all mellowed by dirt.… Lamps sparkle in the gloom [and] before you is the exquisite carving, inlay and delicate patterns of the baikal (chancel) screen. All around you see, dusty and confused, wonderful pieces of wood carving. Behind the screen looms the curve of the apse; on the thick columns and along the walls … are inscriptions in exquisite lettering—Coptic and Arabic. (A. Fortesque, Lesser Eastern Churches [London, 1913], 288)

As with the Orthodox churches, the Divine Liturgy is central to Coptic worship—even services of baptism will end with Communion. The liturgy generally used is that of St. Basil the Great, the liturgies of St. Gregory of Nazianzus and St. Mark being reserved for special occasions. There is a dramatic shape to the service that is made very evident by the involvement of everyone present. Participation is practical, too.

As in the Orthodox church, music is an inseparable part of the liturgy and the whole service is sung from beginning to end—the music being not so much a way of worshipping, but worship itself. Unlike the Orthodox, however, the congregation is emotionally and vocally involved in the refrains of the litanies.

The pace of the liturgy can be very slow (depending on the priest) and the intonations have a hypnotic quality, using a very narrow range and intervals of a semitone or smaller. The responses are congregational and vocally strongly committed.

A choir, or schola, will lead the singing at large gatherings. Choirs are made up of theological students, for knowledge of the music is inseparable from the study of the liturgy. They accompany some chants with cymbal and triangle, a practice introduced during the Middle Ages and somewhat akin to the vocal drones of the Greek monks. The chanting is always in unison and the percussion instruments keep time with a fairly fast and syncopated beat. The Sanctus, an emotional high point in the Divine Liturgy, is much enhanced by this style of accompaniment.

This very ancient liturgical music is quite different from the popular music of modern Egypt, which is often played by Western instruments such as the electric guitar and synthesizer. It can also be something of an endurance test for the younger generation—but they still attend. In Sunday School, though, there is music of a more relaxed and folk-song style. Here the children and young people sing a different collection of Christian songs, some of which may be chants adapted from the liturgy. Instruments can be used that could never be brought into the church, such as violin, flute, piano and drums. As with much Middle Eastern folk music, the instruments decorate and play along with the vocal melody but do not provide additional lines or harmonies.

Since most Christians attend church three times a week, the liturgy and its music becomes very familiar and much treasured. It is at once one of the most ancient of all musical traditions but at the same time a vital and living force in Christian music, remarkable for its variety and richness.

The Ethiopian Church

The instruments of Musick made use of in their rites of Worship are little Drums, which they hang about their Necks, and beat with both their Hands; these are carried even by their Chief Men and by the gravest of their Ecclesiasticks. They have sticks likewise with which they strike the Ground, accompanying the blow with a motion of their whole Bodies. They begin their Consort (that is, music-making) by Stamping their Feet on the Ground, and playing gently on their Instruments, but when they have heated themselves by degrees, they leave off Drumming and fall to leaping, dancing, and clapping their Hands, at the same time straining their Voices to the utmost pitch, till at length they have no Regard either to the Tune, or the Pauses, and seem rather riotous, than a religious, Assembly. For this manner of Worship they cite the Psalm of David, “O clap your Hands, all ye Nations.” (Father J. Lobo, A Voyage to Abyssinia, trans. by Samuel Johnson [London, 1735])

So wrote a Jesuit priest, Jerome Lobo, in 1627. By any standards, Ethiopia is an inhospitable place to live. In the last ten years or so it has been beleaguered by catastrophic famine due to repeated failures of the rains, a disastrous locust plague in 1986, and a malaria epidemic in 1988. The government is constantly in conflict with groups fighting for their independence. It is not surprising that Ethiopia is described as “economically one of the least developed countries in the world.”

In spite of all this, it is a country of lively culture and strong spirituality, both of very long-standing. The story goes that the Ethiopians adopted the Christian faith in about A.D. 328 after the shipwreck of two Coptic Christians, Frumentius and Aedesius, on their shores. From this very early stage, they have maintained strong links with the Coptic church, siding with it in the Chalcedonian schism of 451.

The Ethiopian church also developed a desert monastic tradition from the fifth century onward. Many of the Ethiopian monks were highly educated and by the seventh century had translated the Bible from Syriac, Coptic, and Greek into the language of Ge’ez, which is still used in the Ethiopian church today. Like Coptic, this liturgical language is now quite different from the locally spoken Amharic language.

In its Christian history, Ethiopia has had very little contact with the West. Although it has been evangelized by Jesuits and more recently by Protestant missionaries, it is unique among African countries in having a Christian church which was established before the conversion of most of Europe. That church is strongly supported by at least 22 million members, divided among 20,000 parishes and led by about 250,000 priests! This represents nearly half the population, the rest being Muslims or members of traditional animist religions.

The statistics alone show support for the Christian faith unmatched by any European country. If the number of priests suggests that their title is a nominal one, then the intensity and thoroughness of their training tells a different story. As well as priests there are deacons, monks, and dabtaras. All of these have a knowledge of their Christian music, for it is bonded to the liturgy as closely as in other Eastern churches. To the dabtaras is given the responsibility of preserving the artistic traditions of church worship. After elementary schooling, a dabtara undergoes intense training in traditional music (zema), dance (aquaquam), poetry (qene) and perhaps in theology and church history, too. The task is a huge one and may take twenty years.

In music, the dabtara faces a rigorous study of the traditional hymns and anthems, of which there are many hundreds. The study is sufficiently intensive, for the dabtara must memorize them all. As part of this process he must make his own copy of the whole vast collection, manufacturing his own parchment and coloured inks, binding the books and making leather cases to preserve them. This task alone may take him seven years, during which time he must also practice the chant daily. Then the dabtara must study the sacred dances and how to accompany them.

The third study, ecclesiastical poetry, is by all accounts a highly sophisticated art, resembling (and probably surpassing) the most demanding of Western disciplines. The poems first and foremost have to be a perfect fit to one of the traditional chants, for they will be heard in worship as a commentary on Scripture. The poem has to be written in the ancient church language of Ge’ez and conform to strict rules of grammar. Most important of all, the poems use a host of scriptural symbols that the congregation understands very well. The poet is judged on how subtly and deftly he handles these symbols and all the technicalities of their expression.

Ethiopian Christians treasure their faith and its traditional expression. By this rigorous training, it is handed down accurately from generation to generation, but at the same time, there is room for creativity and a place for new work within its confines.

The reverence in which these traditions are held is delightfully illustrated by the legends which describe their origin. Ethiopian Orthodox Christians believe that all their sacred chant was created by Yared, a saint of the sixth century:

At this time, there were no rules for the famous zema, or liturgical chant. The offices were recited in a low voice. But when the Saviour wanted to establish sacred chant, he thought of Yared and sent three birds to him from the Garden of Eden, which spoke to him with the language of men, and carried him away to the heavenly Jerusalem, and there he learnt their chant from twenty-four heavenly priests.

Back on earth, Yared set to work composing and singing the sacred chants: And when the king and queen heard the sound of his voice they were moved with emotion and they spent the day in listening to him, as did the archbishop, the priests and the nobility of the kingdom. And he appointed the chants for each period of the year … for the Sundays and the festivals of the angels, prophets, martyrs and the just. He did this in three styles: in ge’ez, ‘ezl and araray; and he put into these three nothing far removed from the language of men and the songs of the birds and animals. (M. Powne, Ethiopian Music [Oxford, 1968], 91)

These stories are recorded in a fourteenth-century synaxarium (Lives of the Saints) called the Senkessar, but in reality, the chant is likely to be even older than the time of Yared. It is probable that some direct link exists with the temple music of Jerusalem.

This connection is reinforced by some remarkable circumstantial evidence. For instance, the characteristic shape of many of the churches is circular, and inside are three sections, one inside the other. The outer passage is open to anyone and is where the dabtara sings. The middle section is where the baptized take communion, but the innermost chamber is only for the priests; it houses the tabot, an altar very much like the ark of the covenant, made of wood and draped with a highly decorated cloth. Even the name of the innermost chamber (keddusa keddusan) is clearly connected to the Hebrew kodesh hakkodashim—the holy of holies.

The dance is of course the most striking link with the Old Testament: The veneration accorded to the tabot in Abyssinia [Ethiopia] up to the present day, its carriage in solemn procession accompanied by singing, dancing, beating of staffs or prayer-sticks, rattling of sistra and sounding of other musical instruments remind one most forcefully of the scene in 2 Samuel 6:5, 15, and 16, when David and the people dance round the ark. The entire spectacle, its substance and its atmosphere, has caused all who have witnessed it to feel transported into the times of the Old Testament. (Quoted in M. Powne, Ethiopian Music, 98–99.)

The History of Music in the Greek Orthodox Church

Almost the entire Orthodox liturgy is sung, most often to centuries-old melodic formulas. In addition to chanted liturgical texts, hymns play an important role in Greek Orthodox worship. Over 60,000 hymns, following one of a variety of prescribed patterns, have been written for use in these churches. Though local customs may influence the way in which this music is chanted, most singing follows traditional practice.

Music is uniquely integrated into the worshiping traditions of the Eastern churches. In the Orthodox churches music and liturgy are interdependent. In well-endowed churches the singing is by choirs; in a humble village church, the priest and people sing. Following the injunctions of the church fathers, musical instruments have never been accepted. The sound of the human voice raised in song is central. As Basil the Great wrote as far back as the fourth century: A psalm is tranquillity of soul and the arbitration of peace; it settles one’s tumultuous and seething thoughts.… A psalm creates friendships, unites the separated and reconciles those at enmity. Who can still consider one to be a foe with whom one utters the same prayer to God! Thus Psalmody provides the greatest of all goods, charity by … joining together the people into the concord of a single chorus. (J. McKinnon, Music in Early Christian Literature [Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press, 1987], 65-66)

The church year and its fasts, feasts and celebrations dominates national and home life in a way that is difficult for the Westerner to appreciate: Nobody who has lived and worshipped among Greek Christians for any length of time has but sensed in some measure the extraordinary hold which the recurring cycle of the church’s liturgy has upon the piety of the common people. Nobody who has kept the Great Lent … who has shared in the fast which lies heavy on the nation for forty days … who has known the desolation of the holy and great Friday, when every bell in Greece tolls its lament and the body of the Saviour lies shrouded in flowers in all the village churches … who has been present at the kindling of the new fire and tasted the joy of a world released from the bondage of sin and death—none can have lived through this and not have realised that for the Greek Christian the Gospel is inseparably linked with the liturgy that is unfolded week by week in his parish church. (R. Hammond, The Waters of Marah [London, 1956], 51-52)

Monastic traditions of worship are very strong in the East, and the twenty monastic foundations on Mount Athos in Greece form its cornerstone. For them, life is governed by Daily Offices similar to those of the Western monastic tradition, but for churches in towns and villages only extracts from the full monastic liturgy are celebrated. The most important of these is the Divine Liturgy (that is, Mass or Communion), the central act of worship on Sundays and feast days. The people do not receive Communion without initial preparation and fasting.

The Divine Liturgy

There are three liturgies used by the Orthodox churches today. The Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom is in common use throughout the year; the Liturgy of St. Basil is rather more elaborate and is used only on Christmas Eve and at Epiphany; the Liturgy of St. James (the oldest of the three) is heard only rarely.

The Divine Liturgy of the Orthodox Church follows the pattern of worship that has changed little in 1,500 years. It may be interesting to compare its outline with that of Egeria’s experience of Mass in fifth-century Jerusalem and the outline of the later Roman Mass. It cannot be stressed enough how important a role music plays in the liturgy. Apart from the sermon, the silent prayers, and perhaps the creed, everything is sung.

Chanting

The simplest type of chanting can be heard in the Scripture readings, declaimed to a single note with deviations related to the punctuation. Between about the eighth and thirteenth centuries a simple but unique method was used to indicate the way in which the pitch of the reader’s voice had to be raised or lowered. This ekphonetic (exclamatory) notation consisted of signs written above the beginnings and endings of sentences, although their meanings are still not completely understood. Today ekphonetic notations are still used in some Eastern churches and in the Jewish synagogue.

The psalms used in the Divine Liturgy and those which also form the backbone of the Daily Office are sung to chants belonging to one of eight modes. These modes are similar to those of Western medieval music, being scale-systems whose finals (like key-notes) are the notes D, E, F, and G.

Psalm-singing is elaborated to a similar degree to Western chant. More interestingly, the eight modes are incorporated into the church’s year.

For symbolic reasons buried in antiquity the modes of Byzantine chant are governed by an eight-weekly cycle, the eight modes being changed Sunday by Sunday until the cycle is begun afresh. The systematic organization of all chants into the eight modes is called the oktoechos.

Perhaps the most interesting feature of the modes is the tendency of music written in any one mode to develop a unique character through the use of stock melodic ideas or formulae, a practice known as centonization. This is a feature of many types of music which are created aurally rather than composed on paper.

There is evidence of centonization in Gregorian chant and it is an essential part of Indian classical music, where a rag is given its character not just by the notes of the scales used, but by the melodic ideas used as the basis for improvisation. African master-drumming is based on the same principle, and it is inherent in contemporary jazz.

Hymns

One of the most striking musical features of Orthodox worship must be its hymns, which have been composed in huge numbers from the fourth century onwards. One compilation lists at least 60,000 (Follieri, Initia Hymnorum Ecclesiae Gracae, quoted in the New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians [London, 1980], under the entry “Byzantine Rite”). Byzantine hymns have traditional structures which all have their proper place in the liturgy.

The simplest hymns are one verse long and called troparia (singular troparion). Originally these were short poetic prayers inserted between the verses of a psalm and set to simple music easily memorized by a congregation.

Kontakia are much more extended hymns, being built up of many verses—perhaps thirty or more. They are based on a number of traditional patterns (called hirmoi) which govern the numbers of lines for each verse and the number of syllables and their stresses in each line. The beginning letters of each verse make an acrostic that may spell out the name of the author, or the day and feast for which the kontakion was intended, or perhaps the musical mode to which it was sung. Each verse has a short refrain suitable for participation by choir or congregation. Many kontakia were composed by Romanus in the sixth century.

Kanones became the most complex of all Byzantine hymns and replaced kontakia around the eighth century. In full they consist of nine sections (called odes), the subject of each being based on nine biblical songs:

• Exodus 15:1–19
• Deuteronomy 32:1–43
• 1 Samuel 2:1–10
• Isaiah 26:9–19
• Daniel 3:26–45 and 52–56 (including the deuterocanonical section)
• Daniel 3:57–88 (including the deuterocanonical section)
• Jonah 2:3–10
• Habakkuk 3:2–19
• Luke 1:46–55 (Magnificat)
• Luke 1:68–79 (Benedictus)

As with the kontakia, the odes consist of a verse from a traditional source (the hirmos) followed by a number of troparia modeled on it.

Each ode is sung to a different melody. In practice, kanones in their full form are very long and are only heard nowadays at the important yearly feasts and then only in monasteries and cathedrals. They are sung during the Morning Office and split into three parts (odes 1 to 3, 4 to 6, and 7 to 9). (A glance at the subject matter will suggest why it is included only during Lent.) Between these parts are inserted hymns and a reading. Usually, kanones are drastically shortened so that only the initial hirmoi are sung.

Stichera were a later development of the troparia—hymns sung after a verse of a psalm. In this respect they are similar to Western antiphons. They are divided into different categories according to their subject and the feast for which they are appropriate.

In the last few centuries of the Byzantine Empire, expert singers and composers—maistores—developed a highly elaborate style of kalophonic singing, beautifying the already elaborate chant. The names and compositions of these maistores are known today, Joannes Koukouzeles (about 1280–1370) being the most revered (he is a saint of the Greek Orthodox Church). This unique singing tradition even had a competitive element, maistores rivaling each other in their spectacular elaborations of a given text. The kalophonic tradition lasted until the nineteenth century when Chrysanthos of Madytos revised and simplified the chant to bring it back into closer touch with the common people.

The Byzantine Chant Today

How is Byzantine chant performed today? The answer of course depends on where it is performed, but under no circumstances will it be heard with musical instruments. In a village church, there may very well be no choir, and the chanting will be undertaken by the local priest. If the priest himself is not available, a lay reader will be able to take the role of psaltes (cantor), for the music will be very familiar to regular churchgoers.

In a few city churches in Athens, it is still possible to hear Byzantine chants harmonized in a manner developed in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, but in most monasteries and cathedrals this is not the case. Here the music will be sung in a long-established manner by two choirs standing on either side of the chancel, the left-hand choir led by the lampadarios and right-hand by the protopsaltes. The right-hand choir tends to have the more skilled singers and handles more complex music, though much of the music is antiphonal, the music moving from one choir to the other and back again. Highly skilled cantors will sing the most complex chants (such as the prokeimenon) as solos.

In many monastic choirs (such as that of the Monastery of Saint Simon on Mount Athos) a tradition of two-part singing is preserved. In reality, the second part is not melodic but consists of held notes rather like a drone, a practice dating from about the seventeenth century. The upper part keeps to the traditional chant.

The language used by the church for its traditional music is the Greek of the very earliest years of Christianity, very different from modern Greek, but nonetheless understood and revered by churchgoers.

The music of course has changed since its creation in those early times. How much it still resembles the music of the ancient Byzantine Empire is a difficult question which cannot be answered easily (see M. P. Dragoumis, “The Survival of Byzantine Chant” in E. Wellesz, ed. Studies in Eastern Chant, vol. 1 [Oxford, 1966], 9). But considering the enormous time span from their composition to modern times, the correspondence between ancient manuscripts and the present-day chant is remarkable.